ࡱ> g @bjbjVV 4lr<r<8c%ccp p ppp q q q8Aqtq< q#qr")r)r)rs&>s Js$ϚȔpRsssRsRsȔpp)r)rݔuuuRsZp)rp)ruRsuuR)rz:tb0#>(<epRsRsuRsRsRsRsRsȔȔuRsRsRs#RsRsRsRseRsRsRsRsRsRsRsRsRsc o: Inquiry into the treatment of individuals suspected of people smuggling who say they are children Submission by Edwina Lloyd Solicitor - Blair Criminal Lawyers Sydney NSW 3 February 2012 TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary3 Background..3 Outline of the case of Luco.3 Court Chronology.4 Evidence in Lucos case against issues raised in the discussion paper.5 Incorrect age assessment have lead to significant human rights breaches..6 Documentary and affidavit evidence of age..6 Conclusion - Practical Suggestions7 Executive Summary I wish to make practical suggestions to improve the process for age assessments for young Indonesian crew charged with people smuggling offences that lead to more efficient outcomes for government, and equitable outcomes for detainees. These suggestions will also help Australia to better meet its human rights obligations under the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) and the relevant articles of the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child (UN Committee). Background I write this submission from my own experience defending a young Indonesian person (Luco) charged with people smuggling as an adult and later found to be a juvenile and deported back to his village in Indonesia. Outline of the case of Luco Luco was apprehended by the Australian navy near Ashmore reef on 20 February 2010. When asked his age by navy personnel, Luco replied that he was 15. He was taken to Christmas Island and detained at the Northern Immigration Detention Centre on 24 February. He participated in a Department of Immigration and Citizenship (DIAC) Entry Interview on 25 February. On 1 April he was taken to Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital and underwent a wrist x-ray. The wrist x-ray was examined by [name] who determined Luco to be 19 years or older. He remained in immigration detention for a further 6 months before being taken to Sydney on 14 October 2010 and charged with people smuggling. Luco was interviewed by the AFP. There was an independent person present but by the account of the interview, the independent person remained mute and offered no advice, such as advising Luco the pros and cons of exercising his right to silence. Following this he was taken into custody at MRRC located at Silverwater, NSW. It was not until late December 2010 that my firm was given carriage of his matter Following a second attempt at representations, the Commonwealth withdrew proceedings against Luco. Luco was formally discharged in court on 8 November 2011 and deported home. Court Chronology 19 January 2011: This was the first time the matter was heard at Bankstown Local Court, NSW. On this date we requested an adjournment so we could obtain the CD of the x-ray of Lucos wrist. 7 February 2011: The matter was adjourned until 7 March 2011 on the advice of the NSW Legal Aid Commission who were waiting on an advice from Senior Counsel on the constitutionality of the mandatory legislation. 7 March 2011: As we were still waiting on the x-ray CD, we had the matter adjourned. 4 April 2011: Matter was adjourned until 2 May to give defence time to obtain our own expert report from a radiologist as well as an expert report from a cultural expert and a forensic psychologist. 2 May 2011: Matter was set down for an age determination hearing 20 June 2011 with a mention date of 23 May 2011 for a return of subpoenaed material from the AFP and [name]. 23 May 2011: Subpoena material returned and matter adjourned until 6 June 2011 to confirm the age determination hearing date. 6 June 2011: The Legal Aid Commission NSW had not granted funding for expert reports so the hearing of 20 June was vacated. Matter adjourned until 11 July for expert reports to be filed with the court and the CDPP and to obtain a new hearing date. June 2011: Forensic psychologist visited Luco in custody and conducted psychological testing. Luco was identified as labouring under significant mental impairment. 11 July 2011: Obtained hearing dates of 15 and 16 August. Late July 2011: Representations made to the Director of the CDPP to withdraw charges based on the evidence obtained in the radiologist, cultural and psychologist report. Representations were unsuccessful. 15 August 2011: Age determination hearing. The defence application to the Court, namely that Luco was under 18 years of age at the time of the offence, was refused. Luco was committed to the Sydney District Court for trial. 8 September 2011: Defence filed an application for bail at the Sydney District Court. 9 September 2011: Luco arraigned and given the trial date of 12 June 2012. Defence requested a date in September 2011 for the bail hearing but the CDPP requested October 2011 when their expert would be available. I was in a trial in October so the date of 8 November 2011 was set down for the bail hearing. Between 9/9/11 and 21/10/11 defence engaged Medical statistician [name] to provide a report. 21 October 2011: Defence made a further attempt at representations to the CDPP with the report of [name] and the psychologist report and requested the charges be withdrawn. 23 October 2011: I flew to Indonesia and obtained affidavit evidence of Lucos age from his family. 2 November 2011: Defence served the CDPP with the affidavits to be considered with the earlier representations. 8 November 2011: Charges were formally withdrawn at Sydney District Court and Luco was subsequently released to Villawood Detention Centre and flown to Denpasar. Evidence in Lucos case against issues raised in the discussion paper The following points are raised in relation to the issues outlined in the discussion paper, arising from my experience. Time Spent in Detention prior to formal arrest Luco was detained in immigration detention for 8 months. I am deeply concerned as to the amount of time spent in detention before the charging process began. 8 months is an unreasonable amount of time to wait to be charged and there has been no reasonable explanation as to why it took so long. It is unreasonable because Luco was identified as a crew-member of a vessel bringing asylum seekers into Australian territorial waters. There existed enough physical evidence for the AFP to lay charges upon apprehension. No attempts made to verify Lucos age besides sole reliance on results of a wrist x-ray The AFP abided by Regulation 6C in the Crimes Regulations 1990 solely to establish Lucos age. None of the Australian authorities and their officers (AFP and DIAC) made any attempt to verify Lucos claim that he was a juvenile, such as obtaining documentary evidence, conducting inquiries with Luco himself or by conducting psychological testing or engaging anthropological, cultural or linguistic expertise to conduct focused age interviews. No attempts were made to contact Lucos family members to verify his claim. Expertise of officers carrying out assessments Currently, the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) delegates power to any officer as defined by the Act in section 5 as being authorised to make age assessments. As per section 5, an officer can be an officer of DIAC, AFP, state police or any other officer authorised by the Minister. There is no requirement for any officer to hold any expertise in age assessment practices. Requirement of expertise to conduct x-ray procedure as prescribed by Regulation 6C(5) Given the inquiry will receive submissions from medical practitioners on the x-ray technique there is no need for me to outline my criticisms of this technique currently used by officers to assess age. Those criticisms involve the fact that the use of the x-ray technique to determine chronological age has been condemned worldwide because it is an inappropriate and unreliable tool to determine chronological age. However, I must express my concern at the radiologist engaged by the AFP to carry out these procedures. In the age determination case of Luco, it became apparent to the defence that the radiologist did not have the relevant expertise required by the regulations. 6C(5) of the regulations states that the radiograph must be interpreted by an appropriately qualified person. The radiologist in Lucos case postulated himself to be an expert in paediatric radiology. However, evidence from many cases, including in Lucos hearing revealed that the radiologist is a gastro-radiologist. Incorrect age assessment has lead to significant human rights breaches In the case of Luco, significant human rights breaches have occurred. Luco was treated as an adult in the criminal justice system, and was imprisoned in an adult prison because of an error made in age assessment processes. Following the date of the incorrect determination of age using the x-ray technique, Luco was treated as an adult and spent 13 months in an adult maximum-security remand facility in Silverwater, NSW (MRRC). Luco was not afforded any protection as a vulnerable juvenile or otherwise vulnerable individual. Consequently, Article 37(c) of the CRC has been breached. Article 37(c) provides that no child should be deprived of their liberty. It further states that the child is to be treated in a manner that takes into account the needs of the child, including ensuring the child is separated from adults. In addition, imprisonment should be used as a last resort and for the shortest period of time as per Article 37)(b) of the CRC. Finally, Article 19 provides that the child should be protected from sexual, physical or mental violence. It is unknown but suspected that Luco was a victim to some mental and perhaps sexual violence during his incarceration. The UNHCR has provided guidelines on the use of age assessment practices. None of these were followed in Lucos case. Documentary and affidavit evidence of age Birth Records, School Records, Church Records Just prior to Lucas 15 August 2011 age hearing, the CDPP disclosed 2 birth certificates. Neither were admitted by the Magistrate at Bankstown Local Court as they were not sighted or certified by an Australian legal practitioner. It is common knowledge that the young crew recruited on these boats are poached from impoverished villages where there is a lack of reliable documentary evidence of birth. It is also common knowledge amongst Australian Legal Practitioners, of the standard expected when tendering evidence. My experience in the Local Court is that the court will not accept documentary evidence unless it is accredited by Australian legal practitioners and in a Western style format. This places an unreasonable burden on legal practitioners and the young Indonesian clients and their families to produce documentary evidence that is viewed as credible before a western court. His Honour, in my case indicated that his hands were tied and had no choice but to rely on the documentary evidence produced by the radiologist in his report which determined Luco to be 19 years or older. Affidavit Evidence In 2011, I became aware that there was a similar case to Lucos in QLD where barristers flew to Indonesia to obtain affidavit evidence of age for their clients. I approached NSW Legal Aid Commission for funding and this was approved. I flew to Lucos remote village in Indonesia and returned with affidavits from my clients caregivers, his Aunt, Uncle and his blood sister. The CDPP did not disclose the reasons for withdrawing the charges. Conclusion Practical Suggestions The period of time between apprehension and arrest should be a matter of weeks not months. If there is enough evidence, physical or otherwise, the accused should be charged immediately. If there is not enough physical or other evidence, they should be returned home immediately. There needs to be a permanent legal aid employee(s) based at Christmas Island to provide legal representation prior to any DIAC or other AFP interviews. This is necessary because it is apparent that crew apprehended have no independent legal representative available to them. The Indonesian crew of these boats come from impoverished villages. They have no understanding of Australias criminal justice system. They should be cautioned appropriately which would mean proceeding with an understanding of their cultural background, their linguistic limitations and their ability to defend themselves. There should be independent support persons who is trained in responding to the needs of young Indonesians in these situations. If there is a claim from any individual that they are under the age of 18, this should be treated with the benefit of the doubt and all efforts should be made by the Commonwealth to obtain reliable evidence of their age. Officers should contact the individuals families immediately to notify them of the location of the individual and to be advised of the individuals age. No individual claiming to be under 18 should be remanded to an adult maximum security gaol unless the age of the individual has been determined. Up until that point, the individual should be detained in either an immigration detention for juveniles or in community detention. The Migration Act 1958 (Cth) should replace the definition of officer in regards to age determination assessments in s5 with an officer with expertise in age assessment practices. The officer should conduct focused age interviews with the support of an independent person with legal knowledge. Regulation 6C of the Crimes Regulations 1990 should be removed immediately because it has been discredited worldwide as an inaccurate determiner of chronological age. The Crimes Regulations should be amended to include strict age determination protocols and should include assessments by psychologists, cultural, anthropological and linguistic experts. The CDPP need to make clear what they will accept to rebut the presumption they hold that every individual is an adult. I would be grateful for the opportunity to participate in any hearing related to this inquiry. Kind Regards, Edwina Lloyd Solicitor Blair Criminal Lawyers [mobile] [phone] [email]  HYPERLINK "mailto:"  3 February 2012   NB This is not the real name of my client. As he is a juvenile his name shall remain private.     PAGE  PAGE 1 abr  * V ^ v z ypg^UL^UL^@hk}"h\T5mH sH hXWX5mH sH h$e5mH sH h\T5mH sH h%5mH sH h9 5mH sH h9 h$e5CJmH sH h9 h9 5CJmH sH h9 h$e5CJmH sH h9 h';56CJmH sH h9 h';5CJmH sH h';h';5CJmH sH h';5CJmH sH h';5mH sH h';h';5CJHmH sH h';h4]5CJHmH sH bcdefghijklmnopqr _ gd$egd';gd_$$a$gd';z , : ? @ ]  ) - . / 0 1 2 6 ; D w ǻлвЦН}ui`iuXh:mH sH h-B5mH sH hp hs(5mH sH hs(mH sH hK)mH sH h4]hs(5mH sH h\Th';5mH sH hxL5mH sH hxLhxL5mH sH h0t5mH sH hEhE5mH sH hE5mH sH h%5mH sH h\T5mH sH h\T56mH sH hXWX5mH sH h$e5mH sH " @ . / 0 2 D  " h}'; & Fgd3 ;gdKQ; & Fgd~^gds(; & Fgds(7$8$9DH$gdK)gdxLgdEgd_$ < [ z {   " t { | RWE\ǻxoxd\ddTdhpmH sH hNmH sH h3 h~^mH sH hKQ5mH sH h~^h~^5mH sH h~^5mH sH hHZmH sH hH1mH sH jh~^0J[UmH sH h~^mH sH hmH sH hp hs(5mH sH hEmH sH h$mH sH hp 6mH sH hp mH sH hxmH sH h]|mH sH hs(mH sH &g,xy&r·¤˜wog_g_gVh=Bd5mH sH h_TmH sH h=BdmH sH hG_mH sH hG_5mH sH hxLhG_5mH sH hxLhxL5mH sH hxLh3 5mH sH h:mH sH h1sPh4]mH sH h1sPh.mH sH h1sPmH sH h.mH sH hP$*mH sH h4mH sH h3 hG_mH sH h3 h~^mH sH h xmH sH LrtZgd~^;gdxL; & FgdxLgdN; & Fgd1sP; & Fgd3 >?^_`bj jprͼͱ͠ĕ͌|s|hh~h{mH sH h~5mH sH h~mH sH h{mH sH h{5mH sH h3 h3 mH sH h xmH sH h=Bd5mH sH h3 h=BdmH sH h0idmH sH h3 5mH sH h3 mH sH hHzmH sH h*mH sH h=BdmH sH h.mH sH h.h.mH sH 'rst:?sx>DZkzk| *|}{hS hS mH sH hTmH sH h xmH sH hS 5mH sH hS mH sH h:mH sH hnmH sH hn5mH sH hHzhnmH sH hP mH sH hmH sH hHz5mH sH h.5mH sH hHzmH sH hnhnmH sH -Zk}~<l p!!("##$$%r%%i'p(gd?i; & Fgd?igdr; & FgdB gdh0; & Fgdbgd; & Fgdgds(; & Fgds(gd~^}~;<l !o!p!!!!!!"("/"""|nc[cSKCh^mH sH hbmH sH hh0mH sH h:mH sH hh0hh0mH sH hxhh056mH sH hxh:N&56mH sH hxhb56mH sH hTmH sH h8mH sH hG mH sH hg-mH sH hmH sH hxh56mH sH h-,JmH sH hs(mH sH ht5mH sH hp hs(5mH sH h3 h~^5mH sH """"""""###########$$"$%q%r%%%%%%&&&&ugu_W_hEmH sH hmH sH hxh@56mH sH hxh?i56mH sH hxh56mH sH h?imH sH hr6mH sH hrmH sH hxhB 56mH sH hB mH sH hh0mH sH h#mH sH h +mH sH h$mH sH hE5mH sH h^mH sH hV_mH sH h gmH sH !&&&&''4'5'C'h'i'l''''''(2((((((((())$)%)&))))))))))>**ȷȯ}uh$mH sH h@h@5mH sH h~5mH sH h@hs(5mH sH hxL5mH sH h^mH sH h@mH sH h<>*mH sH h:mH sH h<mH sH h?imH sH hV_mH sH h~mH sH hEmH sH hmH sH h.mH sH *p()))>**+ ,2--. / /6/d/J00l1233_455x555; & Fgd gdE; & Fgd@gds(**++W+]+q+w+y++++,-.. / / //5/6/d/////////I00001~v~nfn^h4]mH sH h@N|mH sH h iAmH sH himH sH h:mH sH hSmH sH hS56mH sH h h 5mH sH h h~5mH sH h hs(5mH sH hs(hs(mH sH hmH sH hJoUmH sH hXPmH sH h#mH sH h$mH sH h~mH sH h5mH sH "12C2^2_2p2w22Q3Z3[3^3m3333333333q4v4w4z4{4444445555w5x5555źؤ~ulh{|5mH sH h@5mH sH hK)hxL5CJmH sH h#mH sH h8JmH sH h1sPmH sH h#mH sH hShs(56mH sH hS56mH sH hShSmH sH h9@mH sH hqPDmH sH h OmH sH h:mH sH h4]mH sH h mH sH '5R66666:7G7H7K88999$999999E:N:d:::;;?;F;];c;;;;<<<-<1<P<Žŭť|qeqh{|h4]6mH sH h{|h4]mH sH h63mH sH h6mH sH hmH sH hfjmH sH hLmH sH h-DmH sH hmH sH h:mH sH h9@mH sH h[~mH sH hR`mH sH hmH sH h1sPmH sH h{|mH sH h5mH sH h{|h{|mH sH '5699e:;<<B==>??|?}????????????gd% h^hgd%h^hgd%; & Fgd{|P<<<<<<<<<< =+=A=B=i=n======>>??????????????ƻƻγγΣƛ{{wphdhh' jh' U h&h&h&h&mH sH h%h%5mH sH h%h%6mH sH h%mH sH hZmH sH h:mH sH h-DmH sH h[~h{|mH sH hR`mH sH h[~mH sH hR`hY6mH sH hx1mH sH h{|hYmH sH h{|h4]mH sH $????@@@@@@f@g@h@j@k@m@n@p@q@s@t@z@{@|@}@~@@@@@@@@@@Ȼuouokuou`uokh>0J\mHnHuh x h x0J\jh x0J\Ujh' Uh' h~^h xCJjh~^h x0J[CJUh_$hs(mH sH jhs|h' <Ujhs|h' <Ujhs|h' <Ujhs|h' <Uh4]hs(mH sH h%h[~mH sH hkmH sH "?@f@g@i@j@l@m@o@p@r@s@|@}@~@@@@@@h]hgdT &`#$gd-,JdYgd_$21h:pv. A!"#$% Ddd  S 2A@?BulletRed"@@b14?۞C:tPt D.n4?۞C:tPtPNG  IHDR \SstEXtSoftwareAdobe ImageReadyqe<$PLTE+擜frWd飪)9GV @ tRNSNIDATx10 $m}Ab׷{G=Y[ pup9kx`/W.% TIENDB`Ddh  S 6A@?BulletBlack"@@bDAݔmg$7 -.nAݔmg$7PNG  IHDR \SstEXtSoftwareAdobe ImageReadyqe<0PLTE(&)Ʃpnqb`c748ECF}SQTY tRNS#]QIDATx9@ BQ{lpێަ>Z *|3D幣 ~o.6W<7ᬖ;Gϝ| 0K5M>*IENDB`Dd T  S "A@?X"@@b4x[K2-.n4x[K2PNG  IHDR#!d`tEXtSoftwareAdobe ImageReadyqe<3PLTEECFSQT748pnqb`c}(&)&tRNS%bIDATxڄ EqH zO-21Ϲ}1` BE2"%',Yt.Ý%w l똫E"%x 09Yf$t4Ī*nyDⰯ#۸SMc X%O0gȚ82D"r=3"E)bTlZ͢CcBe|PUn \jDǢ0Y6rq_-}KrX{ Nn^'v&@@tzIENDB`DdZ  S (A @?Tick"@@b,ѱaՌƺmQGes.nѱaՌƺmQGesPNG  IHDR1/}tEXtSoftwareAdobe ImageReadyqe<3PLTE(&)ECFpnq⩨b`c748ƌ}SQTT+tRNS%b5IDATxڔ[ Ѐ >;䴳rTgȟ=IENDB`jc H^n~:::222222222~~~2222222226>2222222222222222222222222222:22622222222:2222222222>2::2226622222222222626666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666662: 0@P`p2::: 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p:::::2~ OJPJQJ_HmH nH sH tH f`f >Normald7$8$9DH$%B*CJ^J_HmH nHphsH tH` #@Heading 1,Heading 1 - Style A$$d@&/5B*CJ$PJ\_HaJmH nHph sH tH` #PHeading 2,Heading 1 - Style B$$d@&/5B*CJ$PJ\_HaJmH nHph sH tH` #`Heading 3,Heading 2 - Style A$$dh@&+5B*CJ PJ\_HmH nHph sH tH` #pHeading 4,Heading 2 - Style B$$dh@&.5B*CJ PJ\]_HmH nHph sH tH`  #Heading 5,Heading 3 - Style A$$d@&(5B*CJPJ_HmH nHph sH tH` !#Heading 6,Heading 3 - Style B$$d@&+5B*CJPJ]_HmH nHph sH tHDA`D Default Paragraph FontRi@R 0 Table Normal4 l4a (k ( 0No List R@R #0 Balloon Text dCJOJQJ^JaJ`o` #0Balloon Text Char%B*CJOJQJ^JaJmH phsH tot #Bullet - Style A & Fdx%B*CJ^J_HmH nHph sH tHo"  Bullet - Style B# & F edx^e`%B*CJ^J_HmH nHphsH tHo2  Bullet - Style C# & F edP^e`%B*CJ^J_HmH nHphsH tH^"`^ #Caption/6B*CJ\^J_HaJmH nHphMMMsH tHF`SF #pColorful Shading - Accent 2:V0j@ @@j ffjQ LjQL Lj LjQ 44 d`B*ph B*ph B*ph5B*\ph5\ B*ph B*phtobt # Costing Line*  $( Wd^`WCJ_HmH nHsH tH>Oar> # Costing Total5ror #Cross! & F ePP^e`,5B*CJ^J_HaJmH nHphsH tHLoL # Cross Char 5B*CJ^JaJmH phsH > @> #0FooterdB#PoP #0 Footer Char!B*OJQJ^JaJmH phsH o #@'Heading 1 Char,Heading 1 - Style A Char/5B*CJ$OJPJQJ\^JaJmH ph sH o #P'Heading 2 Char,Heading 1 - Style B Char/5B*CJ$OJPJQJ\^JaJmH ph sH o #`'Heading 3 Char,Heading 2 - Style A Char/5B*CJ OJPJQJ\^JaJmH ph sH o #p'Heading 4 Char,Heading 2 - Style B Char25B*CJ OJPJQJ\]^JaJmH ph sH o #'Heading 5 Char,Heading 3 - Style A Char,5B*CJOJPJQJ^JaJmH ph sH o #'Heading 6 Char,Heading 3 - Style B Char/5B*CJOJPJQJ]^JaJmH ph sH |o"| #`Footer - Addresses" (dd)B*CJPJ^J_HaJmH phsH tH ~o2~#Footer - Document Details#d,B*CJ^J_HaJmHnHphsH tHu>B> %#0Header$dB#PoQP $#0 Header Char!B*OJQJ^JaJmH phsH xobx #Heading 4 - Style A &d,5B*CJPJ_HaJmH nHph sH tHxorx #Heading 4 - Style B 'd,5B*CJPJ_HaJmH nHphsH tHo #`Highlight Quote - Attribution#($d&dP a$,6B*CJ^J_HaJmH nHphsH tHo #0Highlight Quote - Bold)$dN .56B*CJ\^J_HmH nHphsH tHo #@Highlight Quote - Left*d$dN (6B*CJ^J_HmH nHphsH tHo #PHighlight Quote - Right+$d&dP a$(6B*CJ^J_HmH nHphsH tHBU`B #0 Hyperlink>*B*CJOJQJph ` # Light List:V-0j9@jZjZjZ jZjZj9jg 442-dfdfd55\5\5\5B*\ph` #Light List - Accent 1:V.0    j9@     jZ     jZ    jZ     jZ    jZ    j9     j|44 U|4      442.dfdfd55\5\5\5B*\ph` #Light List - Accent 2:V/04 Uj9@jZjZjZ jZjZj9jg 442/dfdfd55\5\5\5B*\ph` #Light List - Accent 3:V004 Uj9@jZjZjZ jZjZj9jg 4420dfdfd55\5\5\5B*\phz`z #Light List - Accent 4:V10MMMMMMMMMMMMjZ@MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMjZMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMjZMMMMMMMMMMMMjZ jZMMMMMMMMMMMMjZMMMMMMMMMMMMj9MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMj!44 U MMM4421dfdfd55\5\5\5B*\ph`# #Light List - Accent 5:V20ִִִִ4 UjZ@ִִִִִִjZִִִִִִjZִִִִjZ ִִִִjZִִִִjZִִִִj9ִִִִִjgִִִִִִ ִ4422dfdfd55\5\5\5B*\ph`3 #Light List - Accent 6:V30K33K33K33K334 UjZ@K33K33K33K33K33K33jZK33K33K33K33K33K33jZK33K33K33K33jZ K33K33K33K33jZK33K33K33K33jZK33K33K33K33j9K33K33K33K33K33jgK33K33K33K33K33K33 K334423dfdfd55\5\5\5B*\ph`C # Light Shading:V40jg@ jZjZjZ jZjZjDjQ 4424dfdfd5B*ph5\5\5\5\`S #Light Shading - Accent 1:V50      4 Ujg@      jZ     jZ  jZ   jZ   jZ   jD    jQ      4425dfdfd5B*ph5\5\5\5\`c #Light Shading - Accent 2:V604 Ujg@ jZjZjZ jZjZjDjQ 4426dfdfd5B*ph_5\5\5\5\`s #Light Shading - Accent 3,:V70jg@ jZjZjZ j]|4jZjDjg RRR4427dfdfd5B*ph{{{5\5\5\5\` #Light Shading - Accent 4:V80MMMMMMMMMMMMMMM4 Ujg@MMMMMMMMMMMM jZMMMMMMMMMMMMjZMMMMMMjZ MMMMMMjZMMMMMMMMMjZMMMMMMMMMjDMMMMMMMMMMMMjQMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM MMM4428dfdfd5B*ph9995\5\5\5\` #Light Shading - Accent 5:V90ִִ4 Ujg@ִִִִ jZִִִִjZִִjZ ִִjZִִִjZִִִjDִִִִjQִִִִִ ִ4429dfdfd5B*phs5\5\5\5\` #Light Shading - Accent 6:V:0K33K334 Ujg@K33K33K33K33 ִjZK33K33K33K33jZK33K33jZ K33K33jZK33K33K33jZK33K33K33jDK33K33K33K33jQK33K33K33K33K33 K33442:dfdfd5B*ph8&&5\5\5\5\@@@ #0List Paragraph ;^m$` #PMedium Grid 3 - Accent 3,:V<0jQ@ jQ jQ j; jQ jQ 44 <dh56B*\]ph56B*\]ph56B*\]ph56B*\]phR`R #Medium List 1 - Accent 5:V=0ִִj@ j jִִjִִjִ44 =dHB*ph5\5\5B*\ph OJ$PJQJ$^J` #Medium Shading 1 - Accent 5-:V>0j%@ jj jDjQ ִ442>dfdfd55\5\5\5B*\phror # Normal Indented?Td^T%B*CJ^J_HmH nHphsH tHpop #Normal No Para Space@d%B*CJ^J_HmH nHphsH tHo #Numbered Bullets - Fine PrintA & F d%B*CJ^J_HmH nHphsH tHo" #Numbered Bullets - NormalB & F dx)B*CJ^J_HaJmH nHphsH tH\O2\ #Report - Red TagC ;@xB*CJ$OJQJaJ$ph poBp #Report - SubtitleDd,5B*CJ$^J_HaJ$mH nHphsH tHjoRj #pReport - TitleEd,5B*CJ8^J_HaJ8mH nHphMMMsH tHrobr # Special - 1pt ParaF1B*CJOJQJ^J_HaJmH nHphsH tH|o| #0Special - Custom Spacing Gdx%B*CJ^J_HmH nHphsH tHror #Special - Document typeH#5CJ`^J_HaJ`mH nHsH tHzoz #Table - Col Heading IPP/5B*CJPJ]_HaJmH nHphsH tHbob # Table - Text JPP%B*CJ^J_HmH nHphsH tHt t # Table Grid7:VK0 Kdvov #40mm indent BoldL  d^5CJ_HmH nHsH tHdod #Text - Fine Print MdCJ_HaJmH nHsH tH6o6 # Text - Red B*ph pop P Tick!O & FePP^e`,5B*CJ^J_HaJmH nHphsH tHJoJ O  Tick Char 5B*CJ^JaJmH phsH j`j #pTOC 1Qdx7$8$9DH$,5B*CJ^J_HaJmH nHphsH tHn`n #pTOC 2Rd7$8$9DH$^,5B*CJ^J_HaJmH nHphsH tHl`l #pTOC 3Sd7$8$9DH$^)B*CJ^J_HaJmH nHphsH tHp ap #p TOC HeadingTd^/5B*CJ$PJ\_HaJmH nHph sH tH`S `Light Grid - Accent 2:VU0jF@ j9j; j.jDjD442Udfdfdl5OJ$PJQJ$\^J5OJ$PJQJ$\^J5OJ$PJQJ$\^J5OJ$PJQJ$\^JFV`aF #0FollowedHyperlink >*B*phor #pHighlight Quote - Rule OnlyWd&dP ,6B*CJ ^J_HaJ mH nHphsH tHxox >pFooter - web addressX05B*CJEH ^J_HaJmH nHphsH tHH@H Z~^0 Footnote Text YdCJaJbob Y~^0Footnote Text Char%B*CJOJQJ^JaJmH phsH @&`@ ~^0Footnote ReferenceH*.)@. T0 Page Number:@: \T0TOC 4 ]^ CJOJQJ:@: \T0TOC 5 ^^p CJOJQJ:@: \T0TOC 6 _^L CJOJQJ:@: \T0TOC 7 `^( CJOJQJ:@: \T0TOC 8 a^ CJOJQJ:@: \T0TOC 9 b^ CJOJQJPK![Content_Types].xmlN0EH-J@%ǎǢ|ș$زULTB l,3;rØJB+$G]7O٭Vw={+Zy7I=lZ+j^,g..:yP4˰$sLdD!=GhwRϮ{4\Bw(Ĵ$}:ihIo6{&guZwɡF>ai>NkX%uB&"tq[Rc8ڊukn q.U=6I}PtTG:Ev4hB}{~\wߦs-{"MDόE/oo†REݫ)^Um9_RG5r%{v9QN}s} 1E+s/K CֽmM۝0r][mà^g: XK8,Zښ)45[e+jGv*2F؜fKFMM̚ތYJ5lj #)jD&Tʚ h+pײa3i[nѬsqLpD ig}0N*ceF sp|np;\vsؕ{/=G1^>,seZ qpN4KGbMS5kلԛb}N5: X&64T,ӜK-0y)PSN'E2ÿ&w-I\g;#v(|%8~OD%\w_nN[LŹ(qVhnB9nήIsR *z?ۇf=½HgJ;B%Pp[@`jD 4N6, pT4F~A>%}!(.KLD9܊= u \{{uSM2`p'/2h&7U{́ Ju44+Ǯ7˽UDOL۬2+i7E8Vk+֌KR80X5D9!!?*Bf?u "xA@T_q64)kjnFM]P=al-i}FcW͙4vaavl'SA8|#s?c]pt&;CL@[f_PK! ѐ'theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsM 0wooӺ&݈Э5 6?$Q ,.aic21h:qm@RN;d`o7gK(M&$R(.1r'JЊT8V"AȻHu}|$b{P8g/]QAsم(#L[PK-![Content_Types].xmlPK-!֧6 0_rels/.relsPK-!kytheme/theme/themeManager.xmlPK-!Ntheme/theme/theme1.xmlPK-! ѐ' theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsPK] {8be8 l $$$'z }"&*15P<?@!#%&()+,-/0134 Zp(5?@"$'*.257778X  '!!L# @0(  B S  ?_PictureBullets7888vz^bvz  q u FJ9=OU)-lp7778g8~888C G p s %%''1:13$3777777788g8i8j8l8m8o8p8r8s88833333333378g8~888 AzAXSk|W"~s*LQ"K<<АW>,US?`U@;AZN Be3tn~O5&-tD%iy:f_T^T`56B*CJOJQJo(ph :^`:56CJOJQJo(.X^`X56CJOJQJo(..M u^M `u56CJOJQJo(... J ^J `56CJOJQJo( .... ^ `o(()^`o(.x^x`o(.^`o(.^`5o(.^`.pL^p`L.@ ^@ `.^`.L^`L.^`.^`.PL^P`L. ^`OJQJo( ^`OJ QJ o(o p^p`OJ QJ o( @ ^@ `OJQJo( ^`OJ QJ o(o ^`OJ QJ o( ^`OJQJo( ^`OJ QJ o(o P^P`OJ QJ o(^`o(.^`.pL^p`L.@ ^@ `.^`.L^`L.^`.^`.PL^P`L.)h^h`5B*CJOJQJaJo(phhH^`56B*CJOJQJo(ph% ^ `OJ QJ ^J o(o  ^ `OJ QJ o(  ^ `OJQJo(y^y`OJ QJ ^J o(o I^I`OJ QJ o( ^`OJQJo(^`OJ QJ ^J o(o ^`OJ QJ o(^`o(.^`o(.80^8`0o(..80^8`0o(... ^`o( .... ^`o( ..... `^``o( ...... `^``o(....... `^``o(........"^`B*CJOJQJo(phhHg^g`OJ QJ ^J o(o 7 ^7 `OJ QJ o( ^`OJQJo(^`OJ QJ ^J o(o ^`OJ QJ o( w^w`OJQJo(G^G`OJ QJ ^J o(o ^`OJ QJ o(T^T`56CJOJQJo(^`56CJOJQJo(.^`56CJOJQJo(.. ^ `56CJOJQJo(... !^`!56CJOJQJo( .... :^ `:o(.j :^j `:o(.0:^0`:o(.:^`:o(.%^`5B*CJOJQJo(phhH^`OJ QJ ^J o(o p^p`OJ QJ o( @ ^@ `OJQJo(^`OJ QJ ^J o(o ^`OJ QJ o( ^`OJQJo(^`OJ QJ ^J o(o P^P`OJ QJ o( ^`OJQJo( ^`OJ QJ o(o p^p`OJ QJ o( @ ^@ `OJQJo( ^`OJ QJ o(o ^`OJ QJ o( ^`OJQJo( ^`OJ QJ o(o P^P`OJ QJ o(%^`5B*CJOJQJo(phhH^`OJ QJ ^J o(o p^p`OJ QJ o( @ ^@ `OJQJo(^`OJ QJ ^J o(o ^`OJ QJ o( ^`OJQJo(^`OJ QJ ^J o(o P^P`OJ QJ o(K<U@W>%y;3ٲK<U@W>%iyAz;AZe3tnS?W"5&-ts*XS ޡM                          l        XFX        J,                  7        N5/^& *@]v3 K P p NSfjt>FExH1Vc8J3 B k}"###1#_$$?&:N&P$*/* +g-h021E5';<>9@ iA]ChC-DqPDG-,JxL O1sPKQQT\T_TJoUV*WqcWXWXYHZa\4]b5]~^V_G_`7`R`=Bd0id g hkaEnknr6rEtr0t x@N|{|>}[~S^%fb\~x.?i3#{s(4X`Z:' [#G $LI(#6~e9K)]|`"Hzi#<j8~7d.T@E>-B5#j:$D63: E#pP$eNkS XPx1 @9 $n0ij88@8X@Unknown G*Ax Times New Roman5Symbol3. *Cx Arial7.@ CalibriG=  jMS Mincho-3 fgA.Trebuchet MSK=   jMS Gothic-3 00005" TahomaA& Arial Narrow?= *Cx Courier New;WingdingsACambria Math"1h\/ej/f07J8JHX  7s(2! xx^u\< Edwina Lloyd (Submission 29) Stewart Prins Freyana Irani<         Oh+'0\x   $ 0<DLT Edwina Lloyd (Submission 29)Stewart Prins Normal.dotmFreyana Irani2Microsoft Office Word@@*n:@*n:\/՜.+,D՜.+,H hp|  EMCe7 Edwina Lloyd (Submission 29) Title;GS     ?Oo? _PID_HLINKSContentTypeIdOrder xd_ProgID _CopySource TemplateUrlSubmitter Last Name Submission Type Supplementary Submitter Salutation Submitter Position Submitter First NameOrganisation Name IndividualsDate ReceivedKeywordStatus CommentsContact CommentsPrivacyFrom email addressSubmission numberAHpbmailto:,0x01010078ECC21CFA8F9244BB479F5A6775B3020@`http://ageassessment/inquiryprocesses/Edited Submissions/AmendedEdwinaLloydSubmissionHRC.docxLloyd1NoMs SolicitorEdwinaBlair Criminal Lawyers11;#2012-02-03T00:00:00Z426;#;#53;#;#18;#;#4;#;#12;#;#14;#;#22;#;#27;#;#51;#Needs reviewtChronology of a case 'Luco' - Rifan LASI; independent adult; any 'officer'; insufficient expertise of radiologist;`Contacted re: privacy 3/02/2012 - no reply. Ph: 02 9267 6255 F: 02 9267 6455 M: 0431 686 722Public$edwina@blaircriminallawyers.com.au29  !"#$%&'()*+,-./012345689:;<=>@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root Entry F.z:Data 71Table?WordDocument 4lSummaryInformation(DocumentSummaryInformation8MsoDataStorepz:z:3HAHZ33BM==2 pz:z:Item  t:PropertiesPF4T3TEMU4Z==2 pz:z:Item  PropertiesOCompObjr This value indicates the number of saves or revisions. The application is responsible for updating this value after each revision.   DocumentLibraryFormDocumentLibraryFormDocumentLibraryForm   F Microsoft Word 97-2003 Document MSWordDocWord.Document.89q